Skip to content
Company
  • About Us
  • Meet Our Team
  • Charitable Commitments
  • Testimonials
  • HR Support
  • How We Recruit
  • About Us
  • Meet Our Team
  • Charitable Commitments
  • Testimonials
  • HR Support
  • How We Recruit
Blog
  • Blog Homepage
  • Labour Report
  • White Papers
  • Job Seeker Resources
  • Blog Homepage
  • Labour Report
  • White Papers
  • Job Seeker Resources
Employer

What area of expertise are you hiring in?

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
Job Seeker

What is your area of expertise?

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs

Contact Us

Beware of Recruitment Scams

Our recruiters will never ask for payment or sensitive information such as your passport or banking information.

Read more

BBB Rating: A+

As of 8/7/2024

Click for Profile

What is your area of expertise?

Employer

Job Seeker

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resource
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information And Technology

Are you hiring, or looking for a job?​

Employer
Job Seeker
Employer

What area of expertise are you hiring in?

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
Job Seeker

What is your area of expertise?

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs
GET A QUOTE

Employer Protection During Layoffs: Employment Law Update

12 March 2025
Roper Greyell, Danny Bernstein. An image of employment lawyer Danny Bernstein.
52369

Key legal insights for employers! Lawyer Danny Bernstein on layoffs, class action suits, employee entitlements, and interview questions.

BC UNEMPLOYMENT: CONSTRUCTION

‹ ›

View the Blog Homepage for Areas of Expertise & Sections

Blog Homepage

Employer Protection During Layoffs: Employment Law Update

Get the latest on layoffs, class action suits, employee entitlements, and interview questions. We recently spoke with employment lawyer Danny Bernstein, partner at Roper Greyell LLP. He gave us pertinent information on all of this and more. 

Pressed for time? Skip ahead.

S1: Employer Protection While Preparing for Layoffs

S2: Class Action Suits Against Employers

S3: Employee Entitlement Interpretation Trends

S4: Which Questions are Appropriate to Ask In Interviews?

  

S1: Employer Protection While Preparing for Layoffs

GB: There’s a lot of economic uncertainty at this time. What advice would you give employers who fear they may need to lay employees off in the near future?

DB: What we learned during the pandemic is that a lot of employers are not properly set up to implement significant workforce reductions. If companies need to downsize quickly, that’s generally achieved through temporary layoffs.1

Rules differ by province, but generally speaking, a temporary layoff is no more than a certain number of weeks—13 in British Columbia. Employees are unpaid during that period. If they’re not recalled by the end of the temporary period, then the employment is deemed to be terminated. Then you get into issues of severance owing and so on.

But the BC Employment Standards Act doesn’t actually create an entitlement for employers to make temporary layoffs. It does create protections around the layoffs for employees, but our courts have said that it can be a constructive dismissal to lay someone off without pay, unless you have a contractual ability to do that, or it’s part of an industry standard or company policy.

GB: What do you mean by ‘part of an industry standard’?

DB: In a typical office job, for example, people come in from nine to five, five days a week, all year long. They don’t expect to get sent home – that isn’t ‘industry standard’.

In other industries, layoffs are cyclical. Ski instructors, for example, work for a season and are then sent home. Agriculture and forestry are other examples. You don’t necessarily need contractual provisions in those industries because layoffs are expected—they’re already part of the role.

One of the key lessons we learned post-COVID is that employers who previously never considered layoffs—or didn’t include them in employment terms—should have a clause in their contracts or a policy allowing for temporary layoffs. We now expect the unexpected, and advise our clients to incorporate this language into their contracts.

GB: The pandemic caused a lot of layoffs. How did those cases play out?

DB: A lot of times, the employer would get agreement from the employee before the layoff. If it’s a mutual agreement, then it isn’t being imposed as a unilateral action. Perhaps you offer to extend benefits or other aspects of employment during the layoff.

GB: As an employee, why would I be inclined to agree to this?

DB: You might like your job. During the pandemic, we expected mass claims of terminations. We didn’t expect people to accept temporary layoffs, but they did. I think there was a general acceptance among the workforce that we’re all in this together and that if we all sue the company, the company might close, and they won’t have a job to come back to. They’d rather have a few weeks off and return to work.

As an employee, if you quit and claim constructive dismissal due to a layoff, you can’t be recalled because you won’t be employed anymore. And you may have to go through a dispute process in order to get a severance package.

GB: What should employers do to prepare now if they expect layoffs may be imminent?

A tug of war takes place in front of a judge's gavel. Termination clauses.

DB: If layoffs are imminent and you don’t have good contractual language or policy, then you have to rely on the goodwill you have with your workforce.  Early communication can help, although it can have its own negative consequences if you scare the workforce. But having good employee relations, openness, transparency, and building trust are going to help you get agreement from your workforce. If you have those conversations, you want people to believe you. But certainly for any new hires and promotions, you’ll want to include the right language in the employment contract.

 

S2: Class Action Suits Against Employers

GB: The Federal Court of Canada has ruled that a class action lawsuit against the federal government, alleging that federal employees’ rights were violated by the government’s mandatory vaccination policy, can move ahead. What can you tell us about such class action lawsuits? Should private companies fear something similar?

DB: I don’t know the specifics of that case, but there are sometimes class action lawsuits by groups of employees against their employer for alleged breaches that affected the whole group.

Before any actual determination of the merits of the lawsuit can go ahead, the court must first certify the class. They’ll determine if there are enough common issues among the employees that it makes sense to try the matter as a class rather than individually. Has everyone been wronged in a sufficiently similar way that if you decide one of them, you decide the majority of them? A class action does mean that everyone who has a grievance with their employer can just get together and bring a class action suit, if the issues are different.

GB: What about a group that was collectively sent home from work because they didn’t have a vaccination? Is that a class?

DB: Potentially. Class actions often happen with issues such as overtime—if there’s a claim that an employer failed to follow the rules over a long period of time. There have been banks involved in overtime class actions around who is considered a manager, for example.

The big legal hurdle for the plaintiffs is getting the class certified. Often, if the court determines that it is appropriate to proceed as a class, there will be a settlement.

S3: Employee Entitlement Interpretation Trends

GB: During our last legal update, we spoke about the interpretation of employee entitlements, specifically how Ontario courts are trending ever further in favor of employees. Are you still seeing this?

DB: It’s a hot topic. We are getting new cases where the court has either upheld or struck down language that limits an employee’s entitlements on termination, on a near-weekly basis.

In Ontario, it’s continuing to trend in favor of employees. It’s getting harder and harder for an employer to enforce restrictive termination language. So the need to be careful with drafting is ever-growing.

GB: Help me understand how such ‘legal trends’ materialize. Has the letter of the law changed, or simply the interpretation of the law?

DB: It’s certainly not a change in the law but a gradual shift in perceptions and interpretation of what the law says. I’ll acknowledge that there have been some clever arguments from plaintiff counsel trying to find ways to strike down termination language.

If these new arguments are successful, the next person will then come along and make the same pitch, which can gain traction. That’s what’s happened in Ontario, where we’ve had some longstanding legal notions around contractual interpretation shift in the past few years (in my opinion).

GB: Why do you think lawyers are putting such effort into creating this shift?

DB: I think that, in a lot of cases, the juice is worth the squeeze. Often you’re talking about the difference between someone getting the minimum entitlements under the Employment Standards Act vs common law reasonable notice, which can be multiples higher.

Furthermore, we see a lot of high-value incentive compensation policies and plans where termination impacts bonuses, commissions, or incentive payments. If an employee can argue they are entitled to common law reasonable notice, they may be entitled to the incentive payments that would have occurred during this reasonable notice period, whereas if they only get the Employment Standards minimums, often they won’t be entitled to the incentive payments.  These cases can be worth millions of dollars and are therefore worth litigating for both parties.

GB: Do you anticipate B.C. courts following Ontario’s lead with these interpretations?

DB: So far, we’ve had cases where the BC Supreme Court has refused to be as restrictive in its interpretation of termination clauses. There are a lot of employment lawyers here who would love to change that, but with my management-side lawyer hat on, I hope it stays the same.

 

S4: Which Questions are Appropriate to Ask In Interviews?

GB: Last time we also briefly touched upon employers who ask inappropriate questions during job interviews. I understand that you have prepared some more extensive advice for employers in this regard. 

DB: Yes. I want employers to understand that human rights protections don’t just exist for employees, but for job applicants also. You can get yourself in trouble even before the employment relationship begins if the questions you ask during the interview are discriminatory.

GB: So employers should carefully consider the questions they intend to ask during interviews? 

DB: Yes, and it’s not just questions that are being specifically asked, but the conversation in general. For example, if I’m interviewing you and I start talking about my family, you’ll most likely start talking about yours. It’s not that I asked you about it, but now that information has come up and the question becomes, what am I going to do with that information? WIll it be considered in making hiring decisions? Will the applicant have a perception that it was considered?

GB: What are the ramifications of such situations? 

DB: If somebody doesn’t get a job, they might perceive that such information was the reason. It’s quite possible that they didn’t get the job because there was another candidate who was more qualified, but in their mind it might be because they disclosed that they have a disabled family member, or because they told you that they were considering starting a family. Or because English is their second language. An employer can then find itself in the position of having to defend its decision in a human rights complaint, and prove that those protected characteristics had nothing to do with the decision. 

Another way this comes up is when the candidate does get the job, it could come up again later if they’re passed over for a promotion, or if they get disciplined.  

GB: How can employers get the information they need without wading into troubled waters? 

DB: They should carefully consider the actual requirements of the job and the framing of the questions.

For example, if the job requires a candidate to regularly lift over 50 pounds, don’t ask them if they have a disability that prevents them from doing so.

If the job requires frequent travel, don’t ask if they have a young family who needs them home each night, ask if they’re able to travel.

Don’t ask if they have noisy kids at home, ask if working from home poses a problem.

It’s a matter of framing the question correctly. 

It’s also a matter of really knowing what the job requires. This is often referred to as “bona fide occupational requirements”. If the job only requires a basic proficiency in English, it’s not a bona fide occupational requirement that English is their first language or that they have excellent grammar.

Again, it’s assessing the core requirements of the job and gathering that information in a way that allows the employer to make a reasoned decision, and that recognizes its human rights obligations.

GB: Do you think that most employers are improving in this regard? 

DB: I think it’s become much less likely that employers will ask obviously inappropriate questions, like whether a candidate intends to become pregnant or has any medical issues. I think those days are pretty much gone, although perhaps not entirely. Employers are becoming more familiar with their obligations. Where there is still improvement to be made is in only asking questions that test the core requirements of the job, asking them in an appropriate way, and asking these consistently across all candidates. 

 

Cited Sources 

1 Direct communication with Danny Bernstein

Employer Protection During Layoffs: Employment Law Update
12 March 2025
Table Of Contents
  • References

Henry Goldbeck

President, Founder

key word

  • key word
SEE BIO

Looking for talent?

Seeking job opportunities?

References

tap into cross-industry decision making data

Get advanced access to reports and whitepapers, our quarterly Statistics Canada employments data analysis and read unlimited articles. 

Policy Agreement
Email are sent monthly.
You can unsubscribe at any time
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Leader Spotlight
  • March 14, 2025

From Newcomer to Leader: Monisha Mothilal’s Inspiring Journey

Although Monisha Mothilal has yet to complete her third year in Canada, she has already made a significant impact. As the host of the podcast Newcomers to Trailblazers, she shares the experiences of immigrants navigating life in Canada. She is a sought-after public speaker, serves as Vice President of Tech2Step—a nonprofit dedicated to providing networking […]

San Francisco’s Economy Leads the World Into the Future

  • City Feature, HR Trends
  • May 2, 2024

Downsizing? Know Your Legal Obligations

  • Human Resources & Administration
  • April 14, 2025

Winning Résumés: 7 Steps to Stand Out as a Leader

  • Job Seeker Resources
  • March 17, 2025

Adapting to Modern Donor Expectations in Not-for-profits

  • Not-for-Profit
  • March 12, 2025

Employer Protection During Layoffs: Employment Law Update

  • Observations & Advice
  • March 12, 2025

Recent case studies

1
Case Study: Goldbeck Recruiting’s Strategic Placement for Metro Testing’s PM Estimator Role
2
Case Study: Goldbeck Recruiting’s Strategic Placement for Molycop Plant Manager Position
3
Case Study: Successful Placements by Alessia Pagliaroli for Zetron
4
Case Study: Recruiting a Brand Marketing Specialist for Gray Ridge Eggs

Special features

24 January 2025
How a Side Hustle Made One Professional a Stronger Employee

“I’ve always had the entrepreneurial bug,” admits Adison Wiberg. “Having a small business is something I knew I’d enjoy.”1 Wiberg is the founder, designer, salesperson,...

READ MORE

28 November 2024
The Art and Science Behind B2B Digital Marketing Strategy

“I like the problem-solving element of marketing,” says Colin Rose, Founder, President, and Creative Director at Rose Agency, a digital marketing agency based in Vancouver.1...

READ MORE

Get advanced access to reports and whitepapers, our monthly Statistics Canada employments data analysis and read unlimited articles.

Policy Agreement
Email are sent monthly.
You can unsubscribe at any time
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
GET A QUOTE

ADDRESS

#360-475 West Georgia Street

Vancouver

BC V6B 4M9

View map

BBB Rating: A+

As of 8/7/2024

Click for Profile

CONTACT

  • Phone:+1 (604) 684-1428
  • Toll-Free: +1 (877) 684-1428
  • Email: contact@goldbeck.com
Facebook-f Linkedin

Google Rating

4.8

★★★★★ 4.6/5

200+ reviews

Read the Reviews

privacy POLICY

Terms & Conditions

BBB Rating: A+

As of 8/7/2024

Click for Profile

GET A QUOTE

ADDRESS

#510-475 West Georgia Street

Vancouver

BC V6B 4M9

View map

CONTACT

  • Phone:+1 (604) 684-1428
  • Toll-Free: +1 (877) 684-1428
  • Email: contact@goldbeck.com
Facebook-f Linkedin

Google Rating

4.8

★★★★★ 4.6/5

174 reviews

Write a Review

Website made by Rose Agency

© 2025 All Rights Reserved.

Select an Area of Expertise:

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology

See Job Listings for:

  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs
  • Marketing
  • Human Resources & Administration
  • Engineering
  • Life Sciences
  • Sales
  • Natural Resources
  • Manufacturing & Operations
  • Construction
  • Not-For-Profit
  • Accounting & Finance
  • Executive Search & Consulting
  • Information Technology
  • See All Jobs